After her family moves to the city, Chloe finds her new school to be a scary place where she doesn't fit in. When her father tells her the Bible story of Jonah, Chloe uses her imagination to bring the adventure to life, complete with a nervous prophet (David Osmond), rival gangs of Ninevites who happen to be amazing dancers (Jason Celaya and Jared Young), a hearty band of Spanish mariners (J. Michael Bailey and Josh Tenney), a troubled King and Queen (Brian Allred and Katherine Nelson), a pair of lovable fish named Humphrey (David Ray Burton) and Chum (Korianne Orton Johnson), and a trio of singing crustaceans called the "Crabelles" (Josephine Scere, Brittni Bills Smith, and Marissa Smith). As Chloe likens the story to her own life, she discovers there are no misfits in God's plan.